Don Mattingly
1B | New York Yankees | #23
Age
65
Height
6'0"
Weight
175 lbs
Exp
14 Years
College
None (High School)
Players Collect Score™
7-Day
-1030-Day
—How the Players Collect Score works: The Players Collect Score™ combines performance, market momentum, collectibles and commercial value into a 0–100 score. The colored arrows show each index's 7-day change. The score updates as new data becomes available.
Video Highlights
Don Mattingly highlights from YouTube
Don Mattingly’s Only Playoff Series Was Worth the Wait | 1995 ALDS
Bryce Harper, Alec Bohm, Andrew Painter & Don Mattingly Recap Phillies WC COMEBACK vs. Braves
Did Don Mattingly Guarantee Phillies Win Game 2 vs Braves | ‘We'll win. We'll win today’
Don Mattingly's Awful Decision Cost the Phillies Game 1
Don Mattingly made it clear: Doesn't matter how it happens, just get in 🍾😤 #MLB #phillies
Don Mattingly Phillies Team Speech Before Popping Champagne 🍾 and Celebrating Playoff Trip
Baseballs Greatest Number-#23 Don Mattingly if not then who is & Why? #yankees #baseball #mlb
Don Mattingly analyzes another Phillies base running error
Scan Your Card. See Market Values.
Got a Don Mattingly card? Snap a photo — our AI identifies it and pulls historical sales and live eBay listings in seconds.
Your photo isn't saved — we identify the card, then discard the image.
Most Valuable Collectibles
Top 12 verified sales across marketplaces
$325
$169
83
1SoldCardDon Mattingly Relic Auto 10/10 (PSA 7/10) | 2006 Topps Sterling Moments
2SoldCard2015 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly/Mark McGwire Dual Auto /15 TV9776
3SoldOther1994 FLAIR HOT GLOVES #6 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10
4SoldCard2025 Topps Chrome Cosmic Don Mattingly Launched Into Orbit Auto Black /10
5SoldCard1985 TOPPS SUPER #4 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9
6SoldCard2025 Topps Five Star Don Mattingly Field Access Gold Auto Autograph #/5 Yankees
7SoldOther1991 Coca-Cola Don Mattingly #11 PSA 10 GEM MT New York Yankees
8SoldCardDon Mattingly 2024 Topps 89ASA-DMA Black 1989 35th Anniversary All Star Auto /50
9SoldCard1984 Donruss #248 - DON MATTINGLY RC - ROOKIE - PSA 8 - ✨ NEAR MINT ✨
10SoldOther1986 KAYBEE YOUNG SUPERSTARS #19 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10
11SoldCard2022 Topps Pristine #PA-DMA Don Mattingly PSA 7 NM Auto Yankees
12SoldOtherTCMA 1982 Don Mattingly Columbus Clippers #21 PSA 8 Graded New York Yankees
Verified completed sales only. Rankings factor in sold transaction prices across eBay, COMC, Goldin, Fanatics, and GameStop, but only eBay and COMC items are shown (their listing images are reliable). Each listing is validated against the player's name to prevent misattributed cards from appearing.
Market & Collectibles
Good Coverage
Median Sale
$74
6 sales tracked
Don Mattingly's collectibles trade at a median of $74 across 6 tracked sales. PSA has graded 75,000 of Don Mattingly's cards — 12,500 earned a PSA 10, the hobby's top grade.
PSA Population
How many of this player's cards PSA has graded
Estimated from PSA Population Report data and collector market analysis via web search. Numbers are approximate.
Shop the Market
Search Don Mattingly across the major collectible marketplaces
Fanatics Collect
Premier auctions & buy-now
Goldin
High-end auctions
COMC
Fixed-price marketplace
MySlabs
Graded slabs
Whatnot
Live auctions & breaks
SportsCardsPro
Card price guide
Alt
Card investing & auctions
Auction Houses
Premium sales channels for high-end and vintage collectibles
News Sentiment
Positive
Why
Mattingly is active in coaching, recently praised for his management decisions with the Phillies' Alec Bohm.
MLB Batting
1986 SeasonAVG
.352
OBP
.394
SLG
.573
OPS
.967
Home Runs
31
RBI
113
Runs
117
Hits
238
Doubles
53
Triples
2
Stolen Bases
0
Games
162
Source: BIGFLY MLB · Updated 10/19/2026
Player Search Demand
Google Trends · US · 12-month
Search Demand Score
Top 50%
12-month interest trend
Avg search volume this week, relative to the player's own peak (100)
Top Searches
Related Topics
Last synced Sep 27, 04:52 AM
Legacy Status
Retired — Yankees Legend
Retired — Yankees Legend
MVP
Contract & Value
Retired — N/A
Not Active
Contract details don't apply to retired players.
Career Highlights
Won AL MVP in 1985 with 35 HR and 145 RBI
Set MLB record with 6 grand slams in 1987
9x Gold Glove winner at first base
Hit .340 in 1984 to win batting title
Captain of the New York Yankees
Collectibles on eBay
Live cards, jerseys, memorabilia and more from Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly Signed 2002 Fleer Authentix Ballpark Classics #BC-DM Dual Beckett
Don Mattingly
1984 Fleer #131 Don Mattingly | PSA 9
Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly 1984 Donruss Rookie RC #248 PSA 7 NM New York Yankees HOF MVP Star
Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly Memorabilia Collection
Don Mattingly
Donruss 1984 Don Mattingly #248 Rookie Base Set New York Yankees Card
Don Mattingly
Don Mattingly # 23 New York Jersey Mens XL 1995 Home White Pinstripes
Don Mattingly
2005 Upper Deck Reflections - Cut from the Same Cloth Dual Jersey Don Mattingly,
Don Mattingly
Topps 1984 Topps Don Mattingly Rookie #8 New York Yankees PSA 8
Discover More
Find more rookie cards, memorabilia, jerseys and more from Don Mattingly.
Player Profile & Legacy
Strengths
Community
Join Discussion →Join the conversation around Don Mattingly — share takes, ask questions, and see what other investors are saying.
Career
14 Seasons · 1,785 GamesNew York Yankees
#23
"I just loved to play the game. I loved being at the ballpark."
Don Mattingly is a First Baseman for the New York Yankees with 2,153 career hits, 222 home runs, and 1,099 RBI across 14 seasons (1785 games). Career AVG: .307. Career OPS: 0.832.
2,153
Hits
222
HRs
1,099
RBI
.307
AVG
0.832
OPS
14
SBs
—
Wins
—
ERA
.307 AVG
222 HR
1,099 RBI
0.832 OPS
1,000 Career Hits
2,000 Career Hits
100 Career Home Runs
200 Career Home Runs
500 Career RBI
1,000 Career RBI
500 Career Runs
1,000 Career Runs
Gold Glove
1994
Gold Glove
1993
Lou Gehrig Memorial Award
1993
Gold Glove
1992
Gold Glove
1991
Gold Glove
1989
Gold Glove
1988
TSN All-Star
1987
Gold Glove
1987
Silver Slugger
1987
Gold Glove
1986
TSN Player of the Year
1986
Silver Slugger
1986
TSN All-Star
1986
Most Valuable Player
1985
Gold Glove
1985
Silver Slugger
1985
TSN All-Star
1985
TSN Major League Player of the Year
1985
TSN Player of the Year
1985
TSN Player of the Year
1984
TSN All-Star
1984
Related Athletes
Josue De Paula
Baseball • DH • #
Los Angeles Dodgers
Invest Score
Braylon Payne
Baseball • OF • #
Milwaukee Brewers
Invest Score
JJ Wetherholt
Baseball • 2B • #7
St. Louis Cardinals
Invest Score
Roki Sasaki
Baseball • P • #11
Los Angeles Dodgers
Invest Score