Card Sales
John Elway Card Sales
QB · Denver Broncos · NFL
Every tracked sale of John Elway cards and collectibles, pulled from completed marketplace transactions. Prices reflect what items actually sold for, not asking prices.
Sales Tracked
200
49 in the last 30 days
Median Sale
$56
Middle of tracked sales
Top Sale
$2.0k
Highest verified sale
Marketplaces
1
Sources tracked
Recent Sold Listings
200 tracked2020 PANINI DONRUSS OPTIC DOWNTOWN #DT24 JOHN ELWAY PSA 9 Broncos Super Bowl
$925
View2020 PANINI DONRUSS OPTIC DOWNTOWN #DT24 JOHN ELWAY PSA 9 Broncos Super Bowl
$925
View2020 PANINI DONRUSS OPTIC DOWNTOWN #DT24 JOHN ELWAY PSA 9 Broncos Super Bowl
$925
View1995 Topps Finest Boosters #182 John Elway Refractor with Coating Denver Broncos
$44
View1995 Topps Finest Boosters #182 John Elway Refractor with Coating Denver Broncos
$44
View1995 Topps Finest Boosters #182 John Elway Refractor with Coating Denver Broncos
$44
View2026 Wild Card Fantasy Football Kanji John Elway 1/2 Denver Broncos HOF
$7
View1997 Metal Universe John Elway Titanium Die-Cut #10 of 20 - ONLY 1 in 72 packs !
$46
View2026 Wild Card Fantasy Football Kanji John Elway 1/1 Denver Broncos QB
$11
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic - Uptowns John Elway #23
$160
ViewPanini 2022 Donruss Optic John Elway Denver Broncos #63 NFL Football Card
$8
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic - Uptowns John Elway #23
$160
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2024 DONRUSS OPTIC UPTOWNS FOOTBALL #23 DENVER BRONCOS Q2682
$153
ViewPanini 2022 Donruss Optic John Elway Denver Broncos #63 NFL Football Card
$8
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic Uptowns John Elway #23 Denver Broncos
$165
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2024 DONRUSS OPTIC UPTOWNS FOOTBALL #23 DENVER BRONCOS Q2682
$153
ViewJohn Elway 2024 Panini Donruss Optic Uptowns #23 PSA 9 Denver Broncos
$190
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic Uptowns John Elway #23 Denver Broncos
$165
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic - Uptowns John Elway #23
$160
ViewJohn Elway 2024 Panini Donruss Optic Uptowns #23 PSA 9 Denver Broncos
$190
ViewJohn Elway 2024 Panini Donruss Optic Uptowns #23 PSA 9 Denver Broncos
$190
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2024 DONRUSS OPTIC UPTOWNS FOOTBALL #23 DENVER BRONCOS Q2682
$153
ViewPanini 2022 Donruss Optic John Elway Denver Broncos #63 NFL Football Card
$8
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic Uptowns John Elway #23 Denver Broncos
$165
View1999 Topps Stadium Club Chrome - Never Compromise John Elway #NC37 Refractor
$15
ViewTopps 2005 All-Time Fan Favorites Insert John Elway New York Yankees #15
$5
ViewWild Card 2026 Fantasy Football Steampunk John Elway Gold Foil Match 1/1
$10
ViewWild Card 2026 Fantasy Football Steampunk John Elway Gold Foil Match 1/1
$10
ViewWild Card 2026 Fantasy Football Steampunk John Elway Gold Foil Match 1/1
$10
ViewTopps 2005 All-Time Fan Favorites Insert John Elway New York Yankees #15
$5
View1999 Topps Stadium Club Chrome - Never Compromise John Elway #NC37 Refractor
$15
ViewTopps 2005 All-Time Fan Favorites Insert John Elway New York Yankees #15
$5
View1999 Topps Stadium Club Chrome - Never Compromise John Elway #NC37 Refractor
$15
View2022 Panini Donruss - Crunch Time John Elway #CT-12 - HOF NM-MT
$11
View2022 Panini Donruss - Crunch Time John Elway #CT-12 - HOF NM-MT
$11
ViewJohn Elway 2026 BOWMAN FOOTBALL (40 Box) PLAYER Break #2
$9
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1997 SKYBOX MARVEL METAL UNIVERSE CAPTAIN AMERICA 8 OF 20 #8 Q8128
$56
View2022 Panini Donruss - Crunch Time John Elway #CT-12 - HOF NM-MT
$11
ViewSkyBox 1997 Marvel Metal Universe John Elway Captain America #8/20 Insert
$64
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1997 SKYBOX MARVEL METAL UNIVERSE CAPTAIN AMERICA #8 PSA 9
$425
ViewJohn Elway 2024 Topps Midnight Winter Solstice Nightball /35 #NB-21
$37
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1997 SKYBOX MARVEL METAL UNIVERSE CAPTAIN AMERICA #8 PSA 9
$425
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1997 SKYBOX MARVEL METAL UNIVERSE CAPTAIN AMERICA 8 OF 20 #8 Q8128
$56
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1997 SKYBOX MARVEL METAL UNIVERSE CAPTAIN AMERICA 8 OF 20 #8 Q8128
$56
ViewSkyBox 1997 Marvel Metal Universe John Elway Captain America #8/20 Insert
$64
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1997 SKYBOX MARVEL METAL UNIVERSE CAPTAIN AMERICA #8 PSA 9
$425
ViewJohn Elway 2026 BOWMAN FOOTBALL (40 Box) PLAYER Break #2
$9
ViewSkyBox 1997 Marvel Metal Universe John Elway Captain America #8/20 Insert
$64
ViewJohn Elway 2026 BOWMAN FOOTBALL (40 Box) PLAYER Break #2
$9
View2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome - Star Clusters John Elway, Bo Nix #SCL-13 (RC)
$25
View2025 Immaculate Bo Nix John Elway Payton Manning Patch /49 Broncos!
$130
View2025 Panini Select John Elway/Dan Marino/Jim Kelly Triple Auto Summit /24 ICE SP
$320
ViewPeyton Manning/John Elway 2026 Wild Card 5 Card Draw Back To Back Stacked 1/1 🔥
$7
ViewPeyton Manning / John Elway - Wild Card Back to Back 1/1 - Broncos
$22
View1984 Topps Football Sealed Wax Pack - Possible John Elway Dan Marino Rookies D
$41
ViewJOHN ELWAY, PEYTON MANNING 2024 Leaf Eclectic Pairings Superfractor Prizm 1/1
$60
View1984 Topps Football Sealed Wax Pack - Possible John Elway Dan Marino Rookies C
$53
View2025 Leaf in the Game Used - Patrick Mahomes Dan Marino John Elway Patch /5
$100
ViewJOHN ELWAY DAN MARINO BRETT FAVRE Game Used Patch /30 - Leaf Glory of the Game
$55
View2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome - Star Clusters Peyton Manning, John Elway, Bo Nix...
$23
View2022 Panini Contenders Optic - Legitness John Elway #L-18 - SSP
$45
View2024 Topps Midnight Constellations Bo Nix John Elway #C-6 Rookie RC HOF
$13
View2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome - Star Clusters John Elway, Bo Nix #SCL-13 (RC)
$14
ViewJohn Elway 2024 Bowman Chrome Draft #81D-JE 1981 Design Insert SP Yankees
$30
View2024 Bowman Draft John Elway Bowman 1st 7/75 Jersey Match Yankees
$500
ViewJohn Elway #14 & Terrell Davis 15 BRONZE 1997-1998 SPX Die-Cut Holoview Hologram
$6
View1999 Topps Finest Terrell Davis John Elway Randy Moss Salute Protector #/100
$11
View2016 PANINI BLACK FRANCHISE GOLD JOHN ELWAY TERRELL DAVIS ROD SMITH /225 DENVER
$15
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2026 Fanatics Under Wraps NFL Jersey Volume II 5 Box Break 2783
$21
View2006 Donruss Threads - Generations Ben Roethlisberger, John Elway 007/100
$22
View2024 PANINI PRIZM BLUE WAVE #89 JOHN ELWAY 12/230 PSA 9
$35
ViewNEW 2025 Panini Prizm Black JOHN ELWAY Pigskin Prizm /225 - Denver Broncos
$6
ViewJOHN ELWAY 1998 METAL UNIVERSE DECIDED EDGE CARD
$25
View2007 Leaf Limited #150 John Elway Denver Broncos HOF GU Patch /25 PSA 9 MINT
$42
ViewTopps 80s Lot of 6 Steve Young, Walter Payton, John Elway, Lawrence Taylor White
$27
View1998 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB #100 JOHN ELWAY PSA 10
$35
View2024 Panini Phoenix Treasured Tandems Blue 16/50 John Elway Terrell Davis HOF
$7
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2025 WILD CARD HAUNTED HITS #1/1 DENVER BRONCOS ONE OF ONE
$7
ViewJohn Elway 2026 Wild Card Just the Hits 250 Dino-Might True 1/1 Auto
$175
ViewTopps 1984 Topps John Elway Rookie Base #63 Denver Broncos PSA 8
$179
View1984 Topps - John Elway #63 (RC) Denver Broncos Rookie HOF Legend
$45
View2023 Panini Zenith JOHN ELWAY #9 NM
$7
View1984 Topps #63 John Elway Denver Broncos RC HOF MINT NO RESERVE!
$52
View1984 TOPPS FOOTBALL SET BREAK #63 JOHN ELWAY RC
$55
View1984 Topps John Elway #63 RC
$50
View1984 TOPPS #63 JOHN ELWAY RC BRONCOS HOF PSA 7
$79
View2024 Topps Signature Class Bo Nix John Elway Paramount Pairings Green RC #/150
$10
View1989 Score Supplemental - John Elway #339S SGC 9
$40
View2025 Leaf Pure Pairings Silver Geometric #27 Terry Bradshaw John Elway 1/1 Auto
$116
View2021 Panini Absolute John Elway Kaboom SP #K31 Broncos
$500
ViewJohn Elway Topps 1998 True Champions Broncos Authentic Jersey (2) Card Lot *READ
$11
ViewJohn Elway TOPPS FLAGSHIP FOOTBALL HOBBY CASE 12 BOX BREAK #1
$7
View2024 Panini Prizm John Elway Orange Wave #/60 Broncos
$12
View1995 ZENITH Z-TEAM #ZT7 JOHN ELWAY PSA 9
$82
View1997 Topps #HB9 John Elway Hall Bound
$5
View1990 TOPPS #37 JOHN ELWAY BRONCOS HOF PSA 10
$70
ViewWild Card Black Tie 2026 John Elway Denver Broncos 2/4 Football SDPS-JEN
$10
ViewJohn Elway 150 Football Card Lot **Read Description**
$20
ViewTopps 1984 Topps John Elway #63 Rookie Denver Broncos NFL Football Card
$20
ViewJohn Elway 2026 Leaf Ultimate Sports Multi-Sport 1x Case Break #4
$8
View2019 Panini Prizm Draft Picks Stained Glass #63 John Elway Stanford NM HOF Card
$6
ViewPanini 2025 Flawless Distinguished Patch Auto John Elway Broncos DPA-JEY /10
$365
View1985 TOPPS #238 JOHN ELWAY PSA 8
$35
View1985 Topps Broncos Team Leaders John Elway PSA 10 Gem Mint
$600
View2025 Panini Flawless John Elway Dual Patch Auto Autograph Silver #/20 Broncos
$422
ViewLot(3) 2026 Steam Punk John Elway Color Match True 1/1 , Base 1/1 & 4/4 HOF QB
$37
ViewTopps 1984 John Elway Rookie Base Set #63 Denver Broncos PSA 5 EX Card
$40
ViewPanini 2020 Mosaic Football John Elway #293 No Huddle Blue Prizm /75
$40
ViewDenver Broncos Premium 4-Card Jersey Relic (3) Lot w/John Elway REPRINT RC
$7
View1997 Skybox Metal Universe John Elway Marvel #8 Broncos
$42
View1984 Topps "John Elway" Denver Broncos #63 Rookie (RC) NFL Football Card
$43
View1996 Topps Chrome John Elway #34 Refractor 40th Anniversary Broncos HOF
$50
View2026 Topps Flagship Football John Elway Super Bowl Champion Signatures Auto /
$170
View1984 Topps John Elway #63 Rookie Football Card Denver Broncos *READ*
$50
ViewTopps 1984 Topps John Elway #63 Denver Broncos RC Graded Football Card
$53
View2015 Panini Clear Vision History John Elway Game Used Stanford Bronco Jersey /99
$55
View1984 Topps - John Elway #63 (RC) PSA 8
$158
View1986 Topps Set-Break #112 John Elway NR-MINT *GMCARDS*
$10
View1997 SkyBox Impact JOHN ELWAY RAVE /150 #151 🔥RARE🔥 MINT
$150
View2021 Panini Mosaic John Elway Center Stage Prizm White #/25 Broncos
$8
ViewTopps 1984 Topps John Elway Rookie Base #63 Denver Broncos PSA 8
$175
View1998 Topps Gold Label Class 2 Gold Label #1 John Elway Denver Broncos HOF PSA 10
$116
View1998 Pacific John Elway Gold Crown Die Cuts #9 Broncos
$12
View1984 Topps Set-Break # 63 John Elway RC ! NM-MT OR BETTER *GMCARDS*
$95
View2001 FLEER AUTHORITY WE'RE NO. 1 JERSEY JOHN ELWAY HOF POP 2 PSA 8
$14
View1985 Topps Set-Break #238 John Elway EX-EXMINT *GMCARDS*
$5
ViewPanini 2018 Donruss Optic John Elway Denver Broncos MVP #18 Insert Hologram
$17
ViewTopps 1984 John Elway #63 Denver Broncos Rookie Football Trading Card
$80
ViewJohn Elway 100+ Card Lot Broncos HOF Inserts Numbered 80s 90s 2000s
$23
View2010 Topps John Elway 1984 Anniversary Reprint #63 PSA 8 Broncos
$25
View1985 Topps Set-Break #238 John Elway NR-MINT *GMCARDS*
$6
View1997 SkyBox Marvel Metal Universe John Elway/Captain America #8 Broncos
$35
View1991 Stadium Club #294 John Elway PSA 9
$35
ViewTopps 1984 Topps Football John Elway Denver Broncos #63 Rookie Card - Excellent
$35
ViewTopps 1984 Topps John Elway #63 Rookie Base Set Denver Broncos Football
$36
View1984 Topps Set-Break # 63 John Elway RC ! NR-MINT *GMCARDS*
$37
View1986 Topps Set-Break #112 John Elway NM-MT OR BETTER *GMCARDS*
$41
View1984 Topps - John Elway #63 (RC) plus bonus Joe Montana card
$48
View1996 TOPPS #320 JOHN ELWAY PSA 10
$64
ViewJohn Elway 1984 Topps #63 Denver Broncos Rookie Card RC HIGH GRADE
$96
View2020 PANINI MOSAIC BLUE PRIZM #293 JOHN ELWAY HOF #/99 POP 2 PSA 10
$100
View1998 UD Black Diamond #143 John Elway PSA 10 POP 1 Single Denver Broncos HOF
$94
View🏆🐴 2022 Panini Contenders Gladiators John Elway Insert – Denver Broncos 🐴🏆
$0
ViewPanini 2024 Donruss Optic Uptowns Prizm John Elway #23 Denver Broncos
$138
View1998 Fleer Ultra Exclamation Points John Elway #3EP; RARE
$420
View1997 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB TRIUMVIRATE JOHN ELWAY ATOMIC REFRACTOR #T5B PSA 9!!
$375
View2018 PANINI HONORS JOHN ELWAY FLAWLESS AUTO 1/1
$750
View1984 Topps John Elway #63 PSA 8 Rookie RC HOF 0e1c
$230
View2024 Panini One - One Moment in Time Autographs John Elway #383 (AU) PANINI ONE
$210
View1984 Topps John Elway #63 RC Rookie Broncos PSA 8
$182
ViewTopps Flagship Football 2026 John Elway Super Bowl XXXII Auto SBCS-JEL READ!!!
$175
View1998 SkyBox Premium John Elway #1 Fleet Farm Graded PSA 8 NM-MT
$175
View1984 Topps - John Elway #63 (RC)
$165
View1995 FLAIR #61 JOHN ELWAY PSA 10
$55
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic - Uptowns John Elway #23
$150
View1984 Topps - John Elway #63 (RC)
$66
View1996 Brett Favre PSA 10, Pinnacle TEAM PINNACLE BRETT FAVRE JOHN ELWAY
$145
View1999 Leaf Certified - John Elway #JE7-H Gridiron Gear 💥3-Color Patch💥 /300 (Z)
$103
View1999 PLAYOFF CONTENDERS SSD FINESSE GOLD PT #186 - JOHN ELWAY - (#/25)
$698
View1998 PLAYOFF MOMENTUM HOBBY GOLD - JOHN ELWAY - (#/25)
$357
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic - Uptowns John Elway #23
$303
ViewJohn Elway 1984 Topps RC #63 Graded BGS 8.5 Broncos HOF Rookie QB
$280
View1984 Topps Football #63 John Elway Denver Broncos RC Rookie HOF PSA 9 MINT (PD)
$280
ViewTopps 1984 John Elway #63 Rookie Autograph Grade 10 PSA 8 Denver Broncos
$875
View1995 Topps Finest John Elway Refractor W/Coating #220 PSA 8
$165
View1997 TOPPS MYSTERY FINEST GOLD REFRACTOR - JOHN ELWAY- (1 IN EVERY 25,920 PACKS)
$190
View1997 Skybox Metal Universe John Elway Captain America Broncos 8 of 20 Marvel
$60
ViewTopps 1984 Topps John Elway Rookie #86 Denver Broncos Football Card
$65
View1984 Topps #63 John Elway PSA 7
$70
View2021 Panini Classics Classic Combos Dual Auto Black 1/1 John Elway Terrell Davis
$777
View1998 TOPPS STARS LUMINARIES GOLD #L3 - JOHN ELWAY - (#/50) - PSA 8
$776
View1992 TOPPS #125 JOHN ELWAY HOF ERROR 6 YRS VET SHOULD BE 9 PSA 10
$76
View1999 PLAYOFF CONTENDERS SSD FINESSE GOLD #114 - JOHN ELWAY - (#/25)
$615
View1999 ABSOLUTE SSD COACHES COLLECTION GOLD #36 - JOHN ELWAY - (#/25)
$113
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2025 LEAF METAL AUTHENTICS VOLUME 2 AUTO PLATINUM SHIMMER /5 Q3790
$108
View2026 Topps Flagship Football John Elway Super Bowl On Card Auto SBCS-JEL Broncos
$150
ViewTopps 1984 John Elway Broncos #63 PSA 7 RC Base Set Football Card
$80
View1984 Topps Football Rookie #63 John Elway RC BCCG 8 EX+
$81
View2023 Rookies and Stars Crusade John Elway Pink #/75 PSA 10 Denver Broncos
$80
View2021 Donruss Optic Downtown John Elway DT-24 Case Hit SSP Denver Broncos RARE 10
$400
View2024 Panini Donruss Optic - Uptowns John Elway #23
$335
View1995 PINNACLE TEAM PINNACLE #7 BRETT FAVRE/JOHN ELWAY PSA 10
$300
View2025 Immaculate Football-Players Collection Autographs John Elway /99 Broncos
$250
View2024 Panini Prizm Draft Picks John Elway Black Color Blast #CB28 PSA 10 Stanford
$260
View2000 Donruss Preferred John Elway Dan Marino, Pen Pals Auto #PP-53 PSA 8
$2,025
View2005 UD Ultimate Dual Signed John Elway Peyton Manning Autograph Relic /10 PSA 8
$1,499
View2025 TOPPS CHROME TECMO #11 JOHN ELWAY PSA 8
$546
View2025 Panini Phoenix - Color Blast John Elway #25 PSA 10
$440
ViewJohn Elway 2022 Rookies & Stars Denver Broncos Crusade Black 1/1 CGC 8.5
$183
ViewJOHN ELWAY 2021 PANINI FLAWLESS COLLEGIATE CAMPUS LEGENDS SILVER AUTO /25 Q0631
$214
ViewPanini 2025 Phoenix Color Blast Insert John Elway #25 PSA 9 Broncos
$200
View1996 MOVI Motion Vision 3 card lot ! Barry Sanders John Elway Warren Moon
$10
View2012 Topps Five Star John Elway Veteran Auto Triple Jersey Rainbow Patch #/5
$460
View2025 Flawless John Elway Dual Patch Auto /25 Game Worn
$401
View2025 Topps Chrome Tecmo Bowl JOHN ELWAY Broncos SSP CASE HIT SA1
$810
View1997 Fleer Ultra John Elway Blitzkrieg Die Cut #15 Denver Broncos
$10
ViewPanini Immaculate Collection 2025 John Elway MEM /99 Broncos CM-JEY
$18
View1997 Skybox Metal Universe John Elway Marvel #8 Denver Broncos A JS2
$56
View1997 Skybox Metal Universe: # 8 John Elway Marvel Universe NM-MT OR BETTER
$70
ViewSkyBox 1997 Marvel Metal Universe John Elway Captain America #8/20 Insert
$90
ViewHow this data is built. Each row is a completed sale from a tracked marketplace, filtered so only John Elway items appear. Listing images and prices come from the source marketplace; sales may be added or revised as new data arrives. Nothing here is a valuation or an offer.