Card Sales
Peyton Manning Card Sales
QB · Indianapolis Colts
Every tracked sale of Peyton Manning cards and collectibles, pulled from completed marketplace transactions. Prices reflect what items actually sold for, not asking prices.
Sales Tracked
200
52 in the last 30 days
Median Sale
$36
Middle of tracked sales
Top Sale
$28.1k
Highest verified sale
Marketplaces
2
Sources tracked
Recent Sold Listings
200 tracked2008 Upper Deck Premier Trios Patch #PTP-MBR Tom Brady/Peyton Manning/Phillip Rivers Game-Used Patch Card (#1/1) - BGS NM-MT+ 8.5
$28,088
ViewPanini 2026 Score-A-Treat - Peyton Manning - Haunted House Ghosts /299 - Colts
$5
View1998 Topps Chrome #165 Peyton Manning Rookie Card - PSA GEM MT 10
$1,900
View2006 Topps Paradigm Autograph NFL Logo #AL-PM Peyton Manning Signed Patch Card (#1/1) - PSA NM 7, PSA/DNA GEM MT 10
$6,100
View1998 Collector's Edge - Promos Peyton Manning (RC) Psa 10
$66
View2000 Donruss Preferred Peyton Manning Lettermen #/350 Colts
$6
View2020 Panini National Treasures Peyton Manning Treasured Moments #/99 Colts
$26
View1999 Playoff Absolute SSD Honors Red 183/200 Peyton Manning #AH46 HOF n0c
$40
View2020 Panini Obsidian PEYTON MANNING /100 Electric Etch Purple Prizm **POP 1**
$45
ViewFleer Mystique 2000 Canton Calling Peyton Manning Colts #5 CC /10 Insert
$7
View2000 Bowman's Best Year By Year Refractor #1 Peyton Manning Randy Moss
$20
ViewPeyton Manning 2002 Topps Heritage #86 Retrofractors /557
$40
View2009 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning (Blue Jersey) #TC96 PSA 9 MINT HOF 6ns
$54
View2011 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Blue Refractor /99
$66
View2008 Upper Deck StarQuest Rainbow Red #SQ25 Peyton Manning COLTS HOF
$7
View2014 Prizm Head to Greatest of All-Time Silver Peyton Manning Brett Favre 07ap
$17
View1998 Pacific Peyton Manning Checklist Card#12 NM/Mint Condition
$16
View2025 Topps Finest Peyton Manning RARE Purple 9/125 🔥🔥
$6
View1999 Topps Chrome Hall of Fame #H20 Peyton Manning Colts
$11
View2002 LEAF ROOKIES & STARS #39 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10
$42
View1998 Pacific Revolution Touchdown Laser cuts Peyton Manning Rookie RC HOF 0p5
$91
View2009 Upper Deck Peyton Manning Bombs Away! First Edition BA-12 w/protective Case
$15
View1999 TOPPS STARS STARCARDS 3 STAR #23 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9
$20
View2020 PANINI PHOENIX FLAME THROWERS #23 PEYTON MANNING HOF POP 2 PSA 9
$20
View2020 Panini Phoenix Regeneration Peyton Manning #5 PSA 10 GEM MT HOF
$123
View2024 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Sunday Swag Lazer Refractor #SS-10 Broncos
$1
View1998 Collectors Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning Auto RC #135 PSA Authentic Auto 10
$310
View2024 Leaf Ultimate Sports Peyton Manning Auto Autograph Jersey Holo Bronze #/20
$111
View1998 SPx Finite Peyton Manning Rookie RC #/2700 Colts
$20
View1998 UD Black Diamond Peyton Manning Rookie Diamond #91 PSA 8 RC
$56
View1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning RC #121 PSA 8 Rookie No Coating
$46
View1998 Playoff Absolute Retail Peyton Manning Draft Picks BLUE Die-Cut RC PSA 9 #1
$93
ViewPSA 9 1998 Topps Finest with Coauting- Rookie Peyton Manning #121 (RC)
$76
ViewTopps 1998 Draft Picks Peyton Manning #360 Rookie Base Indianapolis Colts PSA 9
$243
View1998 Black Diamond Rookie Edition Peyton Manning White Onyx RC #/2250
$35
View2025 Topps Resurgence -Peyton Manning Thermal Red Ink Auto Red Surge /5 1st Sale
$820
View2021 Panini Immaculate Peyton Manning Patch Auto/25
$432
View2008 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection Peyton Manning Patch Auto #/15 Colts
$1,750
View1998 Topps Action Flats Kickoff Edition Peyton Manning Rookie RC #K5 Colts
$14
View1998 Fleer Ultra Peyton Manning Rookie RC #201 Colts
$24
View3 Card Peyton Manning BGS Graded Rookie Lot
$64
ViewPEYTON MANNING PSA 9 1998 SKYBOX E-X2001 #15S ROOKIE STAR DATE 2001 COLTS 5879
$702
View1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 RC Colts
$14
View1998 COLLECTOR'S EDGE PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC BECKETT 9.5 GEM MINT
$50
View2016 Absolute Peyton Manning Marks Of Fame Auto Numbers #/18 PSA Authentic 10
$271
View1998 Fleer Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Row 3 Rookie RC #3 Colts
$14
View1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA AUTHENTIC AUTO 10 “HOF ’21”
$1,150
View1998 TOPPS FINEST W/COATING #121 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10
$330
View1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey Lvl 2 Hologold Peyton Manning RC Rookie /50 PSA 8
$611
View1998 BOWMAN CHROME #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9
$241
ViewTopps 2024 Resurgence Arc Flash Autographs Peyton Manning Auto /5 #AFA-PM
$160
View1998 Collector's Edge Holo Peyton Manning ROOKIE #4 - Throwing w/ Ball Refractor
$17
View2016 Panini Certified Peyton Manning Mirror Signatures Black 1/1 #M-PMG Auto
$710
ViewPanini 2016 Unparalleled Peyton Manning #22 Denver Broncos Orange #/99
$8
View2025 Mosaic Peyton Manning Hall of Fame Purple Prizm /49
$25
ViewIconic 1998 Peyton Manning Bowman Rookie Card. Card case & stand included.
$25
View2025 Panini Mosaic - Hall of Fame Peyton Manning #296 Red Sparkle Prizm
$8
ViewNFL Football Card Lot 9 Peyton Manning Dan Marino Faulk Rookie
$23
ViewPeyton Manning REFRACTOR PRIZM HOLO CARD Indianapolis Colts
$18
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2023 TOPPS CHROME COMPOSITE RESURGENCE RUBY SURGE CARD #57 /199
$4
ViewRare 2016 PEYTON MANNING PRIZM ALUMNUS DRAFT PICKS 1/1 PURPLE AUTOGRAPH (HOF)
$560
View2024 Panini Obsidian 85 Peyton Manning Orange Mosaic /24 Indianapolis Colts
$30
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2024 PANINI PRIZM DRAFT FOOTBALL RED /299 #54 Q7687-2
$9
View2001 Upper Deck Peyton Manning UD Auto Autograph Game #PM-AJ Colts
$290
ViewPeyton Manning RC: 1998 Bowman's Best Rookie Card #112
$25
View4-Card Lot Peyton Manning RC #112 Kobe Bryant #181 Michael Jordan #7 #11
$250
View2000 Bowman's Best - Year by Year Peyton Manning, Randy Moss #Y1
$11
View1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Rookie RC #165 Colts
$243
View1998 Bowman Chrome Football Hobby Box Factory Sealed (Peyton Manning, Moss RC)
$883
View1998 Pacific Aurora Peyton Manning NFL Command Rookie RC #5 Colts
$23
View2007 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Xfractors #TC5 Colts
$29
View1998 Topps Stadium Club Marshall Faulk Peyton Manning Double Threat #DT1 Colts
$11
View2013 Topps PEYTON MANNING #TLP-PM Topps Legends Patch - Broncos
$10
View2022 Immaculate Peyton Manning Russell Wilson Past and Present Patch #/99
$22
ViewPeyton Manning 🍒 2000 Pacific Vanguard - Cosmic Force - SP
$8
View2004 Fleer Ultra Platinum Medallion Peyton Manning #146 Missing Serial Number
$56
View1998 Upper Deck Encore Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1 Colts BGS 8
$36
View2014 Topps Finest X-Fractor Peyton Manning #50 Denver Broncos
$10
View2008 Upper Deck First Edition Peyton Manning StarQuest Silver #SQ25 Colts PSA 9
$21
View1998 Topps Finest Series 1 Football Hobby Box Factory Sealed Peyton Manning RC
$800
View2001 Topps Chrome PEYTON MANNING "PERFECT SPIRAL" Refractor 🔥 RARE 🔥
$56
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2025 LEAF 15TH ANNIVERSARY PLATINUM BLUE LAVA /5 #91B-133 Q7128
$8
View2023 Panini Donruss Optic Peyton Manning Downtown! SSP #D-9 Colts
$510
View2025 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Variation Green Geometric Refractor IV 12/99
$19
View1998 Fleer Brilliants Peyton Manning Blue Rookie RC #120B Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT
$644
View2004 E-X Essential Credentials Future Missing Serial Number Peyton Manning BGS 8
$52
View2007 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Blue Refractor #TC44 Colts
$20
View1999 Collector's Edge Odyssey Peyton Manning #66 Colts PSA 9
$21
View1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Interstate Rookie RC #1 Colts SGC 96
$81
View1999 UPPER DECK POWERDECK AUXILIARY POWER #AUX7 PEYTON MANNING HOF PSA 10
$80
View1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Undergrads Refractor ROOKIE PSA 8
$499
View2018 Panini Contenders Optic Legendary Purple Prizm PEYTON MANNING #LC-PM #96/99
$6
View2012 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #161 Refractor Broncos
$14
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2009 BOWMAN DRAFT FOOTBALL WHITE /299 #12 COLTS PSA 7 Q2058
$10
View2020 Flawless Aaron Rodgers Peyton Manning Tom Brady Patch Ruby #/15 PSA 10
$2,294
View2008 Upper Deck Peyton Manning Signature Shots Auto Autograph #SS48 Colts
$261
View2008 Upper Deck Heroes Peyton Manning Green #/350 Colts
$12
View2021 Panini Donruss Peyton Manning Downtown SSP #DT-18 Colts Damaged
$563
ViewPeyton Manning & Randy Moss RC 1998 Collector's Edge Masters 50-pt #'d /3000 ‼️
$35
View2021 Panini Donruss Elite Peyton Manning Teal #/25 Colts
$26
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2025 TOPPS CHROME LEGENDS OF THE GRIDIRON BLUE /150 Q7687-1
$9
View2016 Select National Convention Pink Prizm 13/15 Peyton Manning PSA 10 HOF SSP💎
$308
View2019 Panini Select Peyton Manning Tie Dye Prizm /25 BGS 9.5 Gem Mint Colts SSP💎
$261
View1998 Upper Deck SP Authentic Peyton Manning RC /500 Diecut #14 Colts
$1,195
ViewPEYTON MANNING 1999 BOWMAN'S BEST #95 ATOMIC REFRACTOR 79/100 PSA 8 Appears As 9
$1,300
ViewPanini Illusions 2021 Peyton Manning King of Cards Insert KC-17 Colts
$10
View1998 Skybox Metal Universe Peyton Manning Rookie RC #189 Colts
$24
View2006 Leaf Certified Peyton Manning Matt Leinart Fabric of the Game Jersey #/50
$77
View2021 Eminence Peyton Manning Super Bowl Royalty Signatures Silver Bar Auto #/10
$894
View1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 Rookie RC #15S Colts PSA 9
$598
View1998 Collector's Edge Masters Peyton Manning Silver Rookie /5000 #73 Colts
$21
View1998 Topps Stars - Peyton Manning #67 /8799 (RC)
$20
View1999 Skybox Metal Universe Peyton Manning #77 Colts
$8
View1998 SkyBox E-X2001 #54 Peyton Manning RC Rookie PSA 6 EX-MT COLTS HOF
$36
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2025 PANINI PRIZM DRAFT PICKS PURPLE CRACKED ICE /199 #195 Q7899
$6
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2026 PANINI THE NATIONAL VIP RED ICE PRIZM /99 #PM COLTS Q8117
$6
ViewPeyton Manning Signed 2012 Topps Platinum Football Card #60 Broncos JSA Auto
$100
View1998 Topps Gold Label PEYTON MANNING Rookie Card #20 Indianapolis Colts HOF
$20
ViewPanini 2020 Prestige Gridiron Heritage Peyton Manning used patch-Colts🔥
$8
ViewPeyton Manning 2025 Panini Certified Immortals Mirror Red 25/99
$6
View2012 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Prism Refractor #60 Broncos PSA 10 GEM MINT
$153
View1998 Score - Showcase Series Peyton Manning #PP123 Artist's Proof (RC) COULD GEM
$175
View1999 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning All Etch #AE19 Colts
$15
View1998 Fleer Ultra - Peyton Manning #416 (RC) Colts Broncos NFL HOF
$15
View1998 Topps Action Flats Kickoff Edition Peyton Manning Rookie RC #K5 Colts PSA 8
$32
View2015 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Blue Refractor #/199 Broncos
$26
View2000 Topps Gallery - Gallery of Heroes Peyton Manning #GH5 Indianapolis Colts
$141
ViewPeyton Manning 2005 Finest #FM31 Peyton Manning Finest Moments #/599 Colts
$12
View1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning No Protectors Rookie RC #121 Colts PSA 10
$337
View1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 RC PSA 8
$360
View2026 Leaf Spectacular Tom Brady Peyton Manning Marino Montana QUAD JERSEY 10/15
$100
View1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 RC’s Kobe Bryant Topps Chrome 5 Card Lot
$221
View1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Stock in the Game REFRACTOR #S12 COLTS HOF
$74
View2024 Panini Illusions déjà vu Dual Relic Peyton Manning Anthony Richardson
$8
View2024 Leaf Special Release ARCHIE-PEYTON -ELI MANNING Silver Mojo CGC10 #ELE-105
$55
View2014 Topps Fire Competitive Fire Peyton Manning Eli Manning #CF-MM HOF sm1
$18
ViewCard Draw 2023 Stacked Deck 1/1 Peyton Manning & Eli Manning 2-Card Lot
$12
ViewPeyton Manning-Tony Romo 2008 Ultimate Dual On Card Auto 14/15
$1,025
ViewPEYTON MANNING ELI MANNING 2024 TOPPS MIDNIGHT CONSTELLATIONS #C-22 Q3976
$8
View2025 Panini Donruss Optic - Downtown Duos Peyton Manning, Bo Nix #5
$800
View2024 Leaf Decadence Peyton Manning & Eli Manning Dual Auto 3/10
$325
View2025 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown Duos Peyton Manning Bo Nix #5
$810
View2025 Panini Donruss Optic - Downtown Duos Peyton Manning, Bo Nix #5
$810
ViewIndianapolis Colts Lot Edgerrin James Bobblehead Peyton Manning Cards Pin Keych
$5
View2024 Illusions Peyton Manning Anthony Richardson Dejavu 2 color Patch #23/99
$30
View1998 Fleer Brilliants - Shining Stars Peyton Manning #9SS (RC)
$26
View2009 DONRUSS ELITE STARS GOLD #3 PEYTON MANNING HOF #/899 PSA 10
$61
ViewTopps 1999 Finest Prominent Figures Peyton Manning PF6 /5084 Indianapolis Colts
$25
ViewPanini 2011 Honors Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Jersey Patch #2 70/89
$23
View2024 Topps Signature Class Peyton Manning Veteran Auto Gold /10 Colts RF4
$326
View2007 Upper Deck Artifacts Peyton And Eli Manning Duel Game Used Jerseys #21/25
$130
View2005 Topps Turn Back the Clock Peyton Manning #5 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT
$38
View1998 Peyton Manning Rookie PSA Slab Collector's Edge #189 RC Silver Foil
$20
View2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Peyton Manning Light Years SP #LY-2 Colts
$108
View2008 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Blue Refractor #/150 Colts
$106
View2005 Upper Deck Mini-Football Jersey (7) Peyton Manning / Favre / Urlacher +++
$8
View2007 PLAYOFF NFL PLAYOFFS #42 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10
$37
View1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1 Refractor
$37
View2002 SP LEGENDARY CUTS #22 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10
$44
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2008 Topps Chrome X-FRACTOR SP #TC143 Colts HOF 💎 SHARP MINT 💎
$40
View1998 Bowman Peyton Manning RC #1 Rookie
$20
View2025 Panini Rookies and Stars- Peyton Manning Autograph #82
$138
ViewPEYTON MANNING 1998 FLEER TRADITION FOOTBALL ROOKIE RC #235 COLTS Q7391
$6
View2025 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Legends of the Gridiron Green Refractor #/99
$16
View2007 TOPPS #21 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9
$34
View2009 BOWMAN CHROME #12 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10
$54
View2007 TOPPS #21 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 10
$200
View1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - Endzone X-Press Peyton Manning #11 Die-Cut (RC)
$16
View1998 Upper Deck Encore - Constant Threat Peyton Manning #CT2 (RC)
$15
View1998 Topps Stadium Club - Prime Rookies Peyton Manning #PR10 (RC)
$16
View1999 Topps Finest Peyton Manning W/Coating Refractor #1 PSA 10 MBA Gold Pop 1
$8,103
ViewPEYTON MANNING 1999 TOPPS FINEST #1 GOLD REFRACTOR /100 PSA 10 GEM MINT
$7,500
View2026 Leaf Art of Sport Peyton Manning Arts and Graphs Patch Auto /5
$150
View2026 Wild Card Alumination Just the Hit 1/1 Peyton Manning Broncos MAMMOTH Comix
$12
ViewTopps 1999 Finest Team Finest Peyton Manning T7 Red /500 Indianapolis Colts
$50
ViewTopps 2011 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor #110 Indianapolis Colts NFL
$13
View2007 Topps Chrome League Leaders Refractor Peyton Manning PSA 9 MINT HOF 00br
$72
View1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning ROOKIE #112 AGS 9 Mint
$34
View2014 PANINI PRIZM RED WHITE BLUE #58 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS HOF *NRMT/MINT*
$11
View2025 Panini Prizm Draft Picks - Peyton Manning #195 Purple Ice Prizm /199
$10
View2015 Panini Flawless - Peyton Manning 17/20 #31
$165
View1998 METAL UNIVERSE QUASARS #1 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10
$850
View2003 Upper Deck Honor Roll - PEYTON MANNING - Game Used Jersey - BRONCOS COLTS
$12
View2003 Fleer Ultra Peyton Manning Touchdown Kings Memorabilia Jersey #TK/PM Colts
$16
View2001 UPPER DECK NFL LEGENDS AUTOGRAPH PEYTON MANNING - INDIANAPOLIS COLTS
$130
View1998 Peyton Manning Pacific Revolution Showstoppers RED ROOKIE #16 PSA 10 Pop 3
$500
View2011 Topps Prime - Triple Combo Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers #TC-MRB
$14
ViewPanini 2024 Contenders Optic Peyton Manning Dominance Green Pulsar DOM-PMG PSA 9
$55
View1998 Collector's Edge Masters - Rookie Masters Peyton Manning Rookie Card
$15
ViewPeyton Manning #60 2012 Topps Platinum Denver Broncos
$6
View1999 Stadium Club Chrome Peyton Manning Never Compromise Insert #NC22 Colts
$8
ViewPEYTON MANNING 2026 Topps Chrome Fortune 15 #F15-33 Blue Refractor #073/150
$15
ViewPeyton Manning 2025 Topps Chrome Legends of the Gridiron Aqua /199 #LOG-10
$13
ViewUpper Deck 2006 SPx Winning Combos Peyton Manning Matt Leinart Auto WC-ML
$150
View1998 METAL UNIVERSE #189 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9
$201
View1999 Playoff Momentum SSD - Team Thread Checklist Peyton Manning #TTC 05 (MEM)
$8
ViewPacific 2000 Pro Bowl Die-Cuts Die-Cut Insert Peyton Manning Colts #6
$18
ViewPanini 2021 Prizm Draft Picks On Campus Peyton Manning Tennessee #OC-PM
$110
View1998 Skybox EX 2001 - Peyton Manning #54 (RC)
$38
View2025 Panini Mosaic #296 Peyton Manning Purple No Huddle PSA 10 #/50
$148
ViewHow this data is built. Each row is a completed sale from a tracked marketplace, filtered so only Peyton Manning items appear. Listing images and prices come from the source marketplace; sales may be added or revised as new data arrives. Nothing here is a valuation or an offer.