Card Sales
Don Mattingly Card Sales
1B · New York Yankees · MLB
Every tracked sale of Don Mattingly cards and collectibles, pulled from completed marketplace transactions. Prices reflect what items actually sold for, not asking prices.
Sales Tracked
83
12 in the last 30 days
Median Sale
$22
Middle of tracked sales
Top Sale
$325
Highest verified sale
Marketplaces
1
Sources tracked
Recent Sold Listings
83 trackedDon Mattingly Relic Auto 10/10 (PSA 7/10) | 2006 Topps Sterling Moments
$325
View1988 Star Baseball Don Mattingly Platinum Set (9) 1000 Sets Made DX437
$30
ViewDon Mattingly Signed 1988 Topps Baseball Card All Star #386 Yankees JSA Auto
$50
View2025 Topps Five Star Don Mattingly Field Access Gold Auto Autograph #/5 Yankees
$133
ViewDerek Jeter Don Mattingly 2025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy B2-7 Purple Bronx 2 Patch /15
$30
View2024 Topps Five Star Don Mattingly Auto # 14/20 Yankees
$74
View2025 Topps Chrome Cosmic Don Mattingly Launched Into Orbit Auto Black /10
$192
View2025 Topps Shoebox Treasures Don Mattingly Sepia Filter #/50 New York Yankees
$13
View1991 Topps: #100 Don Mattingly 10 Hits In 1990 PSA 10 GEM MINT
$53
View2025 TOPPS UPDATE SERIES DON MATTINGLY 1990 TOPPS BASEBALL ALL-STARS AUTO 4A246
$43
View2025 Leaf Bronx Legacy Derek Jeter & Don Mattingly NY Yankees GAME-USED Mem /15
$20
View2018 Topps High Tek - Don Mattingly #HT-DM Pattern 1 Waves/Diagonals Green Magma
$9
ViewDon Mattingly 1986 RGI Renata Galasso The Hit Man New York Yankees COMPLETE SET
$20
View1986 Topps - Don Mattingly #180 PSA 8
$13
View1995 Upper Deck STEAL OF A DEAL #SD13 Don Mattingly NEW YORK YANKEES
$13
ViewDon Mattingly Signed 1991 Topps Baseball Card #100 Yankees JSA Auto
$45
View1990 TOPPS TIFFANY - DON MATTINGLY #200 NEW YORK YANKEES
$14
View1986 Topps Don Mattingly PSA 8 - New York Yankees First Base
$14
View1986 Topps - Don Mattingly #180 Collector's Edition (Tiffany) Set Break Fast Fre
$35
View1984 Topps #8 Don Mattingly Rookie SGC 7 Near Mint New York Yankees
$20
View🔥 1986 Topps Tiffany All-Star - DON MATTINGLY #712 - BGS 8.5!!
$20
View1989 Topps Tiffany #700 Don Mattingly New York Yankees
$12
View2015 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly/Mark McGwire Dual Auto /15 TV9776
$285
View1989 Fleer Glossy #258 Don Mattingly New York Yankees
$6
View1991 Coca-Cola Don Mattingly #11 PSA 10 GEM MT New York Yankees
$130
View1989 Topps Tiffany #397 Don Mattingly All-Star New York Yankees
$7
View1988 Score Glossy #658 Don Mattingly Highlights New York Yankees
$7
View1988 Topps Tiffany #2 Don Mattingly Record Breaker New York Yankees
$7
ViewLeaf Metal 2022 Don Mattingly Auto 1/1 Serial BA-DM1 New York Yankees
$93
View2026 TOPPS TRIBUTE #PTGA-DM DON MATTINGLY PILLARS OF THE GAME AUTO GREEN /99
$87
ViewDON MATTINGLY 2025 Leaf Bronx Legacy Big Apple Ink Autograph Auto 1/1
$80
View1988 Score Glossy #1 Don Mattingly New York Yankees
$10
View1986 Topps Tiffany Don Mattingly All Star #712 Yankees PSA 9 New York Yankees
$68
View1985 Topps Tiffany #665 Don Mattingly New York Yankees
$50
View1984 O-Pee-Chee Don Mattingly #8 Rookie RC
$33
ViewTopps 2020 Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Don Mattingly Yankees #85C-28 Gold /50
$47
View1994 Flair #6 Don Mattingly Hot Glove
$25
View1994 FLAIR HOT GLOVES #6 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10
$251
View1985 DONRUSS DIAMOND KINGS #7 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9
$22
View2020 TOPPS '85 TOPPS SILVER PACK CHROME #85C28 DON MATTINGLY NEW YORK YANKEES
$6
View2007 SP Legendary Cuts Don Mattingly When it Was a Game Jersey #WG-DM
$19
ViewFleer 1984 Fleer Don Mattingly RC #131 New York Yankees Base Set Card
$12
View1989 DONRUSS #74 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9
$14
View1990 Topps Don Mattingly #200 lot of 9 | M278 | BB
$6
ViewDon Mattingly 2024 Topps 89ASA-DMA Black 1989 35th Anniversary All Star Auto /50
$120
View2022 Topps Pristine #PA-DMA Don Mattingly PSA 7 NM Auto Yankees
$100
ViewTopps 2026 Dynamic Duals Don Mattingly/Derek Jeter #38 /25 Yankees.
$50
ViewTopps 2025 Tier One Don Mattingly Derek Jeter Dual Relic #DPR-MJ 35/49
$50
View1 UNOPENED 1986 TOPPS MLB RACK PACK - DON MATTINGLY FRONT/ PETE ROSE BACK!!
$13
ViewDon Mattingly oddball lot of 50 Fleer Boxed Set NM-MT or Better 1986 -1990
$21
ViewDon Mattingly 2026 Topps Series 1 1991 Chrome Silver Pack 91C-29 Aqua 139/199
$15
View1990 Topps DoubleHeaders - Don Mattingly Wade Boggs Barry Bonds - Lot of 19
$8
ViewFleer/Topps MLB 4-Card Lot Wade Boggs & Don Mattingly Rookie 1983-85
$40
View2026 Leaf Baseball Nation - Baseball Poster Don Mattingly #PB-8 /75
$6
ViewTopps Project 2020 #240 Don Mattingly By Artist JK5
$8
ViewDon Mattingly 2007 UD SP Legendary Cuts Game Used Memorabilia New York Yankees
$8
View1984 Donruss Don Mattingly Rookie RC #248 New York Yankees
$95
ViewTCMA 1982 Don Mattingly Columbus Clippers #21 PSA 8 Graded New York Yankees
$100
View1982 Donruss 1983 Fleer 1984 Fleer Cal Ripken Jr Wade Boggs Don Mattingly Rookie
$29
View1986 KAYBEE YOUNG SUPERSTARS #19 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10
$103
View1984 Donruss #248 - DON MATTINGLY RC - ROOKIE - PSA 8 - ✨ NEAR MINT ✨
$115
ViewDon Mattingly 2024 Topps Update #LHA-13 Legendary Homefield Advantage SSP
$76
ViewTopps Project 2020 #269 Don Mattingly By Artist Ermsy
$7
ViewTopps Project 2020 #208 Don Mattingly By Artist Naturel
$7
View1985 TOPPS SUPER #4 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9
$180
View1985 TOPPS #665 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES BGS 7.5
$7
View2001 Topps Archives Reserve Don Mattingly RC #49
$6
View2005 Upper Deck Classics - Classic Materials Don Mattingly #MA-MA - NY Yankees
$19
View1984 Fleer - Don Mattingly #131 (RC)
$35
View1988 Score Glossy Don Mattingly #1 PSA 8
$10
ViewDON MATTINGLY 2018 TOPPS LIVING SET BASEBALL #85 NEW YORK YANKEES Q3403
$73
View1984 Topps #8 Don Mattingly RC Yankees Vintage Baseball No Reserve
$11
View1986 TOPPS #180 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES BGS 8.5
$12
ViewDON MATTINGLY 2026 TOPPS CHROME ALL-STAR GREEN MOJO REFRACTOR #70/99 **YANKEES**
$19
View1984 TOPPS #8 DON MATTINGLY RC YANKEES BGS 7.5
$32
View2025 Topps X Bob Ross the Joy of Baseball - Don Mattingly #64 Paint Splatter /99
$50
View1985 Leaf Don Mattingly / Dave Winfield #140 Two For The Title PSA 9 MINT
$15
View1993 SELECT #24 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10
$50
View1984 Topps Baseball Complete Set 1-792 Don Mattingly RC, Darryl Strawberry RC
$48
View1984 Topps - Don Mattingly #8 (RC)
$14
View1986 Topps Baseball Vintage Rack Pack w. Don Mattingly on Back! Clean! NM+ -MB
$15
View1984 Topps - Don Mattingly #8 (RC) New York Yankees Rookie
$15
View2004 Donruss Diamond Kings Heritage Coll Don Mattingly GU Jersey /50 PSA 8
$36
ViewHow this data is built. Each row is a completed sale from a tracked marketplace, filtered so only Don Mattingly items appear. Listing images and prices come from the source marketplace; sales may be added or revised as new data arrives. Nothing here is a valuation or an offer.