Most Valuable Cards
Most Valuable Don Mattingly Cards
1B · New York Yankees · MLB
Don Mattingly cards ranked by what they actually sold for. Only completed sales are counted, and every listing is checked against the athlete's name before it appears.
Top Sale
$325
Highest card sale
Cards Ranked
24
Distinct tracked sales
Avg Top 10
$163
Across the top ten
Marketplaces
1
Sources tracked
1Don Mattingly Relic Auto 10/10 (PSA 7/10) | 2006 Topps Sterling Moments
22015 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly/Mark McGwire Dual Auto /15 TV9776
32025 Topps Chrome Cosmic Don Mattingly Launched Into Orbit Auto Black /10
41985 TOPPS SUPER #4 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 9
52025 Topps Five Star Don Mattingly Field Access Gold Auto Autograph #/5 Yankees
6Don Mattingly 2024 Topps 89ASA-DMA Black 1989 35th Anniversary All Star Auto /50
71984 Donruss #248 - DON MATTINGLY RC - ROOKIE - PSA 8 - ✨ NEAR MINT ✨
82022 Topps Pristine #PA-DMA Don Mattingly PSA 7 NM Auto Yankees
91984 Donruss Don Mattingly Rookie RC #248 New York Yankees
102026 TOPPS TRIBUTE #PTGA-DM DON MATTINGLY PILLARS OF THE GAME AUTO GREEN /99
11Don Mattingly 2024 Topps Update #LHA-13 Legendary Homefield Advantage SSP
122024 Topps Five Star Don Mattingly Auto # 14/20 Yankees
13DON MATTINGLY 2018 TOPPS LIVING SET BASEBALL #85 NEW YORK YANKEES Q3403
141986 Topps Tiffany Don Mattingly All Star #712 Yankees PSA 9 New York Yankees
151991 Topps: #100 Don Mattingly 10 Hits In 1990 PSA 10 GEM MINT
161985 Topps Tiffany #665 Don Mattingly New York Yankees
17Topps 2026 Dynamic Duals Don Mattingly/Derek Jeter #38 /25 Yankees.
18Topps 2025 Tier One Don Mattingly Derek Jeter Dual Relic #DPR-MJ 35/49
192025 Topps X Bob Ross the Joy of Baseball - Don Mattingly #64 Paint Splatter /99
20Don Mattingly Signed 1988 Topps Baseball Card All Star #386 Yankees JSA Auto
211993 SELECT #24 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10
221984 Topps Baseball Complete Set 1-792 Don Mattingly RC, Darryl Strawberry RC
23Topps 2020 Silver Pack 1985 Chrome Don Mattingly Yankees #85C-28 Gold /50
24Don Mattingly Signed 1991 Topps Baseball Card #100 Yankees JSA Auto
Ranking method. Cards are ranked by the price they sold for, not by asking prices or estimates. Sales are deduplicated and checked against Don Mattingly's name, so misattributed listings are excluded. A single high sale reflects one transaction, not a guaranteed value.